Success Story – Lavelle Saves Homeowner from Real Estate Tax Bill Disaster

Litigation • August 20, 2025


Background:

Our client purchased a residential home from a foreclosure sale for about $15,000. The client then renovated the property with over $100,000 worth of improvements. At the closing, he paid the taxes due on the property and deposited sufficient funds with the title company to pay the next installment. The title company failed to pay the taxes in a timely manner, even though they held our client’s payment in escrow, and the property was subsequently sold for delinquent taxes to a third-party buyer. The client’s efforts to redeem the taxes were unsuccessful on his own, so he hired Lavelle Law. We were able to make the title company pay the $15,000 it owed under the title policy, but said policy did not cover the improvements to the property, resulting in a significant 6-figure loss to our client. Lavelle was also able to negotiate a repurchase agreement with the tax buyer, which allowed our client to stay and live with his family in the residence while Lavelle moved for judgment against the Cook County Indemnity Fund since our client was an innocent party. Lavelle obtained judgment against the Indemnity Fund for 90% of the value of the property, $245,000, which it then assigned to the tax buyer in exchange for reconveyance of the property back to our client and payment of attorney fees he was forced to expend in Court to rectify this wrong. 


Challenges:

This involved many parties, various property tax laws, the Indemnity Fund, and a novel approach to solving this problem for our client.


Result:

In the end, our client clawed back ownership of his family’s home and was made whole on the attorney fees he was forced to pay to rectify this unfortunate situation. 


Matt Sheahin

Matthew Sheahin

Shareholder


It was very satisfying to return our client the ownership of his family’s home that he lost due to no fault of his own, solely because of a mistake by a title company. While it involved various parties and multiple contested motions, we were able to make our client whole on his losses and his attorney fees and protect him and his family. 


Contact Matt Sheahin to discuss your legal needs.

847-705-7555 or msheahin@lavellelaw.com


“Matthew Sheahin and his team at Lavelle Law are the best at what they do. I was told by one attorney at another law firm that my case wasn’t even credible enough to fight for or take on, so I found these guys at Lavelle Law, and they got the job done.”

More News & Resources

Lavelle Law News and Events

IL Condominium Law: Updates, HOA Strategies, & Financing Insights - a presentation recording
November 24, 2025
Daday and Kish discussed the essentials of Illinois condominium and common interest community association law. The presentation highlighted recent legal updates impacting HOA operations and addressed key issues in collections and safeguarding the financial interests of the association.
Understanding Grandparent Visitation Rights in Illinois
By Elizabeth C. Thompson November 19, 2025
While Illinois law recognizes that grandparents can play a vital role in a child’s life, it also strongly defers to the rights of parents. A grandparent seeking visitation must overcome a high legal threshold and demonstrate that denial of contact would likely harm the child’s well-being.
Behind the Scenes of Our 2025 Food Drive Delivery Day!
By Lavelle Law Charities November 17, 2025
The 2025 Lavelle Law Charities Food Drive wrapped up excitingly on October 24, 2025! After weeks of heartfelt community giving, Lavelle Law team members personally delivered an enormous haul to the Schaumburg Township Food Pantry.
Impact of Partial Government Shutdown on IRS – Day 41
By Timothy M. Hughes November 10, 2025
Impact of Partial Government Shutdown on IRS – Day 41: Due to the current lapse in appropriations, IRS operations are limited. However, the underlying tax law remains in effect, and all taxpayers must continue to meet their tax obligations as normal.
$65 Million Sale of Business - Lavelle Law Success Story
By Business Law October 29, 2025
$65 Million Sale of Business – a Lavelle Law Success Story. We were able to effectively negotiate the terms of a complex sale in a manner that enabled both buyer and seller to achieve their objectives.
Free Event. Learn the nuts and bolts of Illinois condominium law.
By Stephen G. Daday and Robyn K. Kish October 27, 2025
Explore the nuts and bolts of condominium law and gain actionable strategies to navigate today’s condominium and HOA challenges in Illinois.
New law provides expanded protection for Illinois residents, increasing key debtor exemptions.
By Timothy M. Hughes October 15, 2025
The Illinois General Assembly enacted Public Act 1738, amending several provisions of the Illinois Code of Civil Procedure to raise debtor exemption limits effective 1.1.26. The new law provides expanded protection for residents, marking the most significant increase to the state’s exemption statutes in over a decade.
Be proactive and put your home in a trust to avoid the time, hassle, and expense of probate court.
By Heather A. McCollum October 13, 2025
A crucial estate planning tool that many people in Illinois overlook is putting their home in a trust. Placing your house in a revocable trust offers multiple benefits. It avoids probate, which can save your family time and money after your death.
IRS Has Started to Phase Out Paper Tax Refund Checks
By Timothy M. Hughes October 10, 2025
In response to Executive Order 14247 requiring the Internal Revenue Service to eliminate the use of physical checks, the U.S. Department of the Treasury announced that paper tax refund checks for individual taxpayers will be phased out.
Join us in our food drive efforts!
By Lavelle Law Charities October 1, 2025
The 2025 Lavelle Law Charities Food Drive benefiting the Schaumburg Township Food Pantry has begun! Join us in our efforts to bring food, dignity, and hope to residents in need who rely on the food pantry. The need is greater than ever this year, as the food pantry serves over 1,300 households each month!
More Posts