Success Story – Lavelle Saves Homeowner from Real Estate Tax Bill Disaster

Litigation • August 20, 2025


Background:

Our client purchased a residential home from a foreclosure sale for about $15,000. The client then renovated the property with over $100,000 worth of improvements. At the closing, he paid the taxes due on the property and deposited sufficient funds with the title company to pay the next installment. The title company failed to pay the taxes in a timely manner, even though they held our client’s payment in escrow, and the property was subsequently sold for delinquent taxes to a third-party buyer. The client’s efforts to redeem the taxes were unsuccessful on his own, so he hired Lavelle Law. We were able to make the title company pay the $15,000 it owed under the title policy, but said policy did not cover the improvements to the property, resulting in a significant 6-figure loss to our client. Lavelle was also able to negotiate a repurchase agreement with the tax buyer, which allowed our client to stay and live with his family in the residence while Lavelle moved for judgment against the Cook County Indemnity Fund since our client was an innocent party. Lavelle obtained judgment against the Indemnity Fund for 90% of the value of the property, $245,000, which it then assigned to the tax buyer in exchange for reconveyance of the property back to our client and payment of attorney fees he was forced to expend in Court to rectify this wrong. 


Challenges:

This involved many parties, various property tax laws, the Indemnity Fund, and a novel approach to solving this problem for our client.


Result:

In the end, our client clawed back ownership of his family’s home and was made whole on the attorney fees he was forced to pay to rectify this unfortunate situation. 


Matt Sheahin

Matthew Sheahin

Shareholder


"It was very satisfying to return our client the ownership of his family’s home that he lost due to no fault of his own, solely because of a mistake by a title company. While it involved various parties and multiple contested motions, we were able to make our client whole on his losses and his attorney fees and protect him and his family."


Contact Matt Sheahin to discuss your legal needs.

847-705-7555 or msheahin@lavellelaw.com


“Matthew Sheahin and his team at Lavelle Law are the best at what they do. I was told by one attorney at another law firm that my case wasn’t even credible enough to fight for or take on, so I found these guys at Lavelle Law, and they got the job done.”

More News & Resources

Lavelle Law News and Events

BOI reports with FinCEN no longer required for condo, HOAs, other associations, board members.
By Robyn K. Kish August 17, 2026
FinCEN update: Condo, HOAs, and other common interest community associations no longer have to file BOI reports with FinCEN. Volunteer board members are no longer required to report their personal information to the federal government simply because they sit on an association’s board of directors.
Tax-Smart Year-End Planning: Key 2026 Tax Changes & Strategies for Success
By Lavelle Law August 11, 2026
Discover the latest tax law updates and planning opportunities that can help you reduce taxes, protect wealth, and prepare for the future.
IRS Announces Guidance on the Expansion of Paid Family and Medical Leave
By Timothy M. Hughes August 10, 2026
On August 5, 2026, the Internal Revenue Service issued Notice 2026-28 providing guidance on the employer credit for paid family and medical leave (“PFML”) under the Working Families Tax Cuts (“WFTC”). The WFTC makes permanent and expands eligibility and coverage for employers offering PFML benefits to employees.
Federal Rule 68 Offers of Judgment: An Underutilized Tool for Defense Counsel
By Sarah J. Reusché August 7, 2026
Many litigators are familiar with Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 68, but few fully appreciate its strategic value in the defense arsenal. Rule 68 can be a powerful tool for influencing settlement negotiations, and in some cases, limiting a plaintiff’s ability to recover post-offer attorneys’ fees.
Judge Says “You’re Out!” to Stalker Ex  - a Lavelle Law Success Story
By Family Law Practice Group July 28, 2026
A client came to us needing protection from an ex-boyfriend who wouldn’t take no for an answer. She broke up with him after he used her indoor pet camera to spy on her without her permission, then surveilled her at her home and chased her through a parking lot.
Type F Reorganization
By Frank J. Portera July 28, 2026
Thinking about selling your business? In this video, Lavelle Law attorney Frank Portera explains how a Type F Reorganization can create tax efficiencies and simplify the sale process by reducing the need for third-party consents.
6 reasons why you shouldn’t rely on AI for legal advice.
By Sarah J. Reusché and Shelley McCarthy July 17, 2026
Thinking about using AI to represent yourself in litigation? Think again. It is well-documented that pro se litigants are less likely to prevail compared to their represented counterparts. Regardless, AI has provided people with a false sense of security, tempting them to represent themselves regardless.
Representation and Warranties Insurance Democratization: A Game Changer for Many Deals
By Steven A. Migala July 13, 2026
Representations and warranties insurance (“RWI”) for mergers and acquisitions (“M&A”) is more accessible than ever due to increasing democratization in the market. Now, RWI can be a viable option for smaller, mid-market deals.
IRS Announces Simplified Penalty Relief
By Timothy M. Hughes July 10, 2026
On July 8, 2026, the Internal Revenue Service announced a new automatic process to provide penalty relief for taxpayers with a history of filing and paying on time, reducing the need for those taxpayers to request assistance in addressing penalty relief.
NDAs in the Spotlight: What Swift and Kelce’s Wedding Reveals About Protecting Your Privacy.
By Theodore M. McGinn June 30, 2026
High-profile couples like Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce are taking strict steps to protect their privacy. Reports confirm that wedding guests must sign non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) before receiving event details. This highlights how NDAs help individuals and businesses safeguard sensitive information.
More Posts