Why the Motor Vehicle Franchise Model Enhances Competition and Protects Consumers More Than the Direct-to-Consumer Model from OEMs like Tesla

Sarah J. Reusché • August 14, 2025


Recently, more OEMs like Tesla, Rivian, Lucid, and Polestar have implemented a direct-to-consumer approach that many state motor vehicle dealer laws are intended to prohibit. On May 27, 2025, the National Automobile Dealers Association (NADA) submitted a Public Comment, explaining: 

  1. the franchise model is the best new-car sales model for consumers; 
  2. franchise laws are an appropriate exercise of state power in the context of federalism; and 
  3. the franchise model does not create any of the harms that its opponents assert. 


This article summarizes NADA’s statement defending state franchise laws.


First, the modern dealer franchise model is the most effective means of distribution for new vehicle sales. Why? NADA explains that a recent study conducted by Oliver Wyman provides conclusive evidence that the franchise model creates salutary intra-brand competition and allows for customer-by-customer price optimization, both of which provide consumers with a better overall experience and lower end price. The intra-brand competition allows for geographically close dealers to compete with one another for the local business, giving the dealers the ability to provide specialized financing and trade-in options that other business models cannot.


In addition to furnishing the lowest price to consumers, the franchise dealer model helps consumers by providing service and warranty repairs for vehicles, even if the OEM were to go out of business (as seen in 2008 and 2009 with the bankruptcies of Saad, Frisker, and Suzuki). The benefit to consumers under warranty is even greater because now OEMs must reimburse dealers for maintenance, and the consumer ultimately saves. The dealer, as the intermediary, creates a shield for the consumer from predatory OEM tactics, such as producing low-quality vehicles for a marginal profit at the cost of consumer safety.


Second, because federal antitrust laws significantly constrain the ability of dealers to act collectively against OEMs, the only way to protect consumers from the broad overreach of OEM power is through state franchise laws. The abuse of power by OEMs is well-documented, ranging from threatening termination or a shorter-term franchise agreement and pressuring dealers to accept slow-moving inventory, to coercing dealers to make unnecessary, costly facility changes and engage in two-tiered pricing where some dealers receive preferential pricing from the OEM. After the federal antitrust laws shackled the modern dealer franchise from seeking and exercising economic self-help, the states determined that the importance of franchise laws is so paramount that all 50 states have enacted dealership laws.


Third, NADA emphasizes that the rise of direct-to-consumer electric vehicle companies such as Tesla, Rivian, Lucid, and Polestar creates serious risks for consumers. The data shows that franchise dealers offer much greater vehicle options at lower prices and are on track to sell more electric vehicles than direct-selling OEMs in 2025. Moreover, a consumer’s ability to get a car serviced at one of these direct-to-consumer OEMs can be extremely difficult. For example, there are only three Rivian facilities in Illinois that can perform repairs on Rivian vehicles. 


Lavelle Law’s dealership practice group represents dealers in Illinois and Wisconsin in a variety of issues impacting their franchise. Contact Sarah Reusché at sreusche@lavellelaw.com or 847-241-1795 for a free consultation.


More News & Resources

Lavelle Law News and Events

Divorce in 56 Days - a Lavelle Law Success Story
By Family Law Practice Group • November 18, 2026
Divorce is never easy, but it doesn't have to be prolonged or combative. When both parties are committed to a fair outcome and have attorneys focused on resolving the matter efficiently, a divorce can be completed in far less time than many people expect.
What Lenders Need to Know about UCC Article 9’s Commercial Reasonableness Standards After Marchi
By Steven A. Migala • November 17, 2026
When a borrower defaults on a loan, a lender often seeks to repossess and liquidate the collateral securing that debt. However, lenders are constrained in how they conduct those sales by Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code and its standard of commercial reasonableness under UCC Section 9-610(b).
IRS Expands Tax Pro Account for Business Client Payments
By Timothy M. Hughes • November 10, 2026
The Internal Revenue Service announced last week that authorized tax professionals can now make certain payments on behalf of their business clients through Tax Pro Account.
Illinois Condo and HOA Boards: Adopt a Written Collection Policy by January 1, 2027
By Robyn K. Kish • November 5, 2026
By January 1, 2027, condominium and common interest community associations in Illinois must adopt a written collection policy. Under the new law, an association that has not adopted the required policy will be prohibited from initiating legal action to collect delinquent assessments and other common expenses.
Lavelle Law Game Show Event Goes Buzzer to Buzzer
November 4, 2026
Lavelle Law Game Show Event Goes Buzzer to Buzzer - Lavelle Law in Schaumburg has grown over the last 30 years to become a multi-faceted law firm, with more than 40 attorneys who are experienced in numerous areas of law. But last month, the firm upped its game, so to speak.
Join us on 11.8.26 and learn to spot the red flags of fiduciary breach and know your rights.
By Lavelle Law • October 19, 2026
Lavelle Law Attorneys Kaiser and Kokoszka share stories from trust administration disputes, plus red flags of a fiduciary breach and how to protect yourself. Register today for "Tales from the Trenches on Trust Administration"
Banking and Business – October 2026
By Steven A. Migala • October 14, 2026
Federal Banking Regulators Clarify What Financial Institutions Can Tell Customers About Fraud Investigations and Account Closures
Tax Scams to Watch for Related to the One, Big, Beautiful Bill
By Timothy M. Hughes • October 10, 2026
Taxpayers should watch for the following OBBB-related scams and take steps to protect their personal and financial information.
Options and Tips for Selling Your Business - a Lavelle Law Minute video.
By Kerry M. Lavelle • September 29, 2026
Thinking of selling your business ahead of retirement? Business owners should begin preparing when they enter the “red zone” before retirement - not wait until they’re ready to retire. Kerry Lavelle explains this and more in the Lavelle Law Minute video, "Options and Tips for Selling Your Business."
Court Denies Petition to Remove Executor - Major Probate Litigation Defense Victory
By Probate Litigation • September 23, 2026
Court Denies Petition to Remove Executor - Major Probate Litigation Defense Victory - A Lavelle Law Success Story.
More Posts