Banking and Business – November 2026

Steven A. Migala • November 17, 2026

What Lenders Need to Know about UCC Article 9’s Commercial Reasonableness Standards After the Marchi Decision

Banking and Business


Introduction


When a borrower defaults on a loan, a lender often seeks to repossess and liquidate the collateral securing that debt. However, lenders are constrained in how they conduct those sales by Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) and its standard of commercial reasonableness under UCC Section 9-610(b). 810 ILCS 5/9-610(b). A recent case from the Illinois Appellate Court, Marchi v. Centrust Bank, N.A. (2026 IL App (1st) 231476-U), offers a lesson to lenders about how a private sale may not be commercially reasonable.


Commercial Reasonableness Standard


Under UCC Section 9-610(b), whenever a lender liquidates repossessed collateral through either a public or private sale, every single aspect of that disposition, including the method, manner, time, place, and terms must be commercially reasonable. The law places the burden of proof squarely on the lender to demonstrate that its sale process met this standard. If a court finds that the lender failed to conduct a commercially reasonable sale, UCC Section 9-626(3)-(4) provides a rebuttable presumption that a properly conducted, commercially reasonable sale would have generated sufficient proceeds to pay off the debt in full. Unless the lender can successfully present enough evidence proving what a commercially reasonable sale would have brought in, its right to sue the borrower or personal guarantors for any remaining balance, known as a deficiency judgment, is eliminated.


The Marchi Decision


In Marchi, Centrust Bank extended over $1.5 million in SBA loans and a line of credit to MCI, a wedding dress manufacturer, secured by the company’s equipment, inventory, and accounts receivable, as well as personal guarantees from shareholders David Marchi and Robert Goodrich. After payment defaults occurred, the bank declared a default, redirected customer payments to itself, and pursued a private Article 9 sale of the business assets. Although early appraisals and financial records valued the collateral at approximately $3.8 million, a subsequent appraisal (which excluded certain disputed assets and a revised inventory assessment) dropped that valuation to $275,000. The bank ultimately sold the assets privately for $775,000 to a group involving Marchi and Goodrich, with the bank fully financing the purchase itself. Centrust then filed a lawsuit against Marchi and Goodrich as guarantors to collect the remaining unpaid loan deficiency. Following a multi-day trial and appeal, the court ruled that Centrust’s sale was commercially unreasonable. Because the bank did not attempt to rebut the Section 9-626 presumption, the guarantors owed nothing, wiping out the bank’s deficiency claim entirely.


In evaluating what constitutes a “commercially reasonable” disposition, the appellate court emphasized that while sale price is relevant, process, marketing efforts, and the totality of the circumstances matter just as much as the final dollar amount. The court highlighted four major flaws in the bank's strategy that rendered the process unreasonable. First, the bank conducted very limited marketing efforts relative to the specialized nature and value of the assets. Second, the bank disrupted MCI’s ongoing operations and harmed its goodwill during the sales period by redirecting customer payments to itself. Third, the bank fully financed the buyer’s acquisition in a private transaction, which invited judicial scrutiny regarding whether the deal was truly an arm’s-length transaction. Finally, the bank relied on vastly conflicting valuation estimates reconstructed years after the sale closed, rather than establishing fair market value up front.


Takeaways for Lenders


Marchi reminds lenders who decide to pursue private sales that they must adhere to a commercially reasonable process including the method, manner, time, place, and terms of disposition. Lenders should conduct adequate marketing and obtain appraisals before the sale. Because no court supervises a private sale in advance, the only opportunity for borrowers and guarantors to challenge a sale’s commercial reasonableness is after the closing, thus making private sales riskier than court-supervised sales. Litigation takes time, and when a trial later occurs, the market has shifted and memories and other evidence of commercial reasonableness may deteriorate.

 

Notably, if this dispute had arisen after January 2026, the bank would have had an additional option of seeking the appointment of a receiver under the Illinois Receivership Act, 765 ILCS 1090/1 et seq. (Act). Rather than conducting a private, unsupervised UCC Article 9 sale and risking years of post-sale commercial-reasonableness litigation, a lender proceeding under the Act can seek court supervision of a private sale or other disposition through the receivership process. Doing so accelerates the dispute over commercial reasonableness to having it occur before the sale. Lenders considering this option should budget time and resources for it and view it as mitigating the risk of an unsupervised private sale.

 

If you have any questions about UCC Article 9, please contact me at smigala@lavellelaw.com or (847) 705-7555. Thanks to Dylan Degabli for helping me write this article.



Attorney Steven Migala is a Shareholder of Lavelle Law, Ltd., leading its transactional practice groups, focusing on corporate, M&A, commercial real estate, and commercial lending matters. He authors the Banking and Business newsletter, which covers relevant topics in banking, business, securities, and M&A. He is a former chair of the Chicago Bar Association's Corporation and Business Law Committee and served as a member of various civic commissions and chamber of commerce boards.

More News & Resources

Lavelle Law News and Events

IRS Expands Tax Pro Account for Business Client Payments
By Timothy M. Hughes • November 10, 2026
The Internal Revenue Service announced last week that authorized tax professionals can now make certain payments on behalf of their business clients through Tax Pro Account.
Illinois Condo and HOA Boards: Adopt a Written Collection Policy by January 1, 2027
By Robyn K. Kish • November 5, 2026
By January 1, 2027, condominium and common interest community associations in Illinois must adopt a written collection policy. Under the new law, an association that has not adopted the required policy will be prohibited from initiating legal action to collect delinquent assessments and other common expenses.
Lavelle Law Game Show Event Goes Buzzer to Buzzer
November 4, 2026
Lavelle Law Game Show Event Goes Buzzer to Buzzer - Lavelle Law in Schaumburg has grown over the last 30 years to become a multi-faceted law firm, with more than 40 attorneys who are experienced in numerous areas of law. But last month, the firm upped its game, so to speak.
Join us on 11.8.26 and learn to spot the red flags of fiduciary breach and know your rights.
By Lavelle Law • October 19, 2026
Lavelle Law Attorneys Kaiser and Kokoszka share stories from trust administration disputes, plus red flags of a fiduciary breach and how to protect yourself. Register today for "Tales from the Trenches on Trust Administration"
Banking and Business – October 2026
By Steven A. Migala • October 14, 2026
Federal Banking Regulators Clarify What Financial Institutions Can Tell Customers About Fraud Investigations and Account Closures
Tax Scams to Watch for Related to the One, Big, Beautiful Bill
By Timothy M. Hughes • October 10, 2026
Taxpayers should watch for the following OBBB-related scams and take steps to protect their personal and financial information.
Options and Tips for Selling Your Business - a Lavelle Law Minute video.
By Kerry M. Lavelle • September 29, 2026
Thinking of selling your business ahead of retirement? Business owners should begin preparing when they enter the “red zone” before retirement - not wait until they’re ready to retire. Kerry Lavelle explains this and more in the Lavelle Law Minute video, "Options and Tips for Selling Your Business."
Court Denies Petition to Remove Executor - Major Probate Litigation Defense Victory
By Probate Litigation • September 23, 2026
Court Denies Petition to Remove Executor - Major Probate Litigation Defense Victory - A Lavelle Law Success Story.
IRS Launches Digitally Authenticated Tax Compliance Report
By Timothy M. Hughes • September 10, 2026
On August 20, 2026, the Internal Revenue Service announced a digitally authenticated Tax Compliance Report available through IRS Individual Online Accounts. Taxpayers can securely obtain and download the report when applying for a job, a loan, a government benefit, or another service that requires tax compliance info.
BOI reports with FinCEN no longer required for condo, HOAs, other associations, board members.
By Robyn K. Kish • August 17, 2026
FinCEN update: Condo, HOAs, and other common interest community associations no longer have to file BOI reports with FinCEN. Volunteer board members are no longer required to report their personal information to the federal government simply because they sit on an association’s board of directors.
More Posts