Success Story – Shareholder Steven Migala Provides Expert Witness Testimony in Breach of Fiduciary Duty and Fraud Case

Litigation • September 17, 2024


Background:

Shareholder Steven Migala provided expert witness testimony to a Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP trial team, assisting them to obtain a jury verdict in Cook County for its client, Michael Eggum, who sued his former restaurant business co-owner Ryan Kowalis for fraud and breach of fiduciary duty regarding Eggum’s investments in the restaurant co-owned by Kowalis. The evidence at trial included Mr. Migala’s expert opinion/report and testimony concerning the interpretation of key contract documents. 

 

Challenges:

For this project, Steve and his team researched and produced an expert opinion letter / report concerning the interpretation of key contract documents, including a combined Stock Purchase Agreement and Shareholder Agreement. Mr. Migala ardently defended our firm’s opinions at deposition and at trial, persuasively explaining to the jury the meaning of various terms and conditions.

 

Result:

On September 4, a Cook County Circuit Court jury found Kowalis liable for fraudulently inducing Eggum to invest the money he saved while serving 10 tours of combat duty in Afghanistan and Iraq into the restaurant business that Kowalis co-owned and for which he acted as an officer and director. The jury found Kowalis liable for fraud and breach of fiduciary duty and awarded Eggum almost $400,000, which included $113,837 in compensatory damages and almost $300,000 in punitive damages. 


Expert Witness Success Story

Steven A. Migala

Shareholder


My team and I were pleased to assist the Taft trial team as its rebuttal expert witness on this case to achieve a favorable jury verdict for a deserving plaintiff.


Contact Steve Migala to discuss your legal needs.

847-705-7555 or smigala@lavellelaw.com.



“Steve’s expert witness testimony and analysis of the investment contract was incredibly persuasive at the jury trial. His balanced thoughtful testimony was clearly impactful on the jury. Despite the defendant's lawyer trying to push Steve to suggest that the investment funds could have been sent to any account, his opinion testimony was crystal clear – the money was directed and paid to the company's account and essentially could not thereafter be moved without unanimous shareholder approval. The jury clearly followed Steve’s testimony and the trial evidence, in finding the defendant liable for fraud in the inducement by clear and convincing evidence. We look forward to working with Steve on other cases!”

Todd Rowden – Taft Law Partner


More News & Resources

Lavelle Law News and Events

Don’t record a conversation without knowing the law in Illinois!
By Nataly Kaiser July 29, 2025
Do you know it’s a felony in Illinois if you record a conversation without consent? The Illinois Eavesdropping Statute prohibits the secret recording of private conversations without the consent of all parties involved. Protect yourself – Get consent before you hit record! Nataly Kaiser explains.
Now through 10-1-25, Lavelle Law is offering a special discounted rate on powers of attorney for col
By Jackie R. Luthringshausen July 24, 2025
Summer Special! - Now through 10-1-25, Lavelle Law is offering a special discounted rate on powers of attorney for college-bound students and young adults. Don't send your child to college without POA docs in place! Contact Attorney Luthringshausen to start the process. jluthringshausen@lavellelaw.com or 847-705-7555
A summary of The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) and its tax implications.
By Steven A. Migala July 22, 2025
The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), enacted on July 4, 2025, as Pub. L. No. 119-21, permanently extends and modifies key provisions from the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) while introducing new tax benefits and limitations. The law affects individuals, seniors, children, businesses, and charitable organizations.
An in-depth discussion of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act and its tax implications.
By Steven A. Migala and guest Ed Brooks July 21, 2025
Lavelle Law Shareholder Steven Migala and DHJJ Financial Principal Ed Brooks join host Jim Mitchell for an in-depth look at the new U.S. tax legislation, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, and discuss how it will impact both businesses and individuals.
An in-depth discussion of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act and its tax implications.
By Steven A. Migala and guest Ed Brooks July 21, 2025
Lavelle Law Shareholder Steven Migala and DHJJ Financial Principal Ed Brooks join host Jim Mitchell for an in-depth look at the new U.S. tax legislation, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, and discuss how it will impact both businesses and individuals.
What is a fee-shifting provision?
By Sarah J. Reusché July 15, 2025
In the United States, the "American Rule" generally requires each party in a legal dispute to cover their own attorney's fees, regardless of the case's outcome. However, exceptions exist where a judge may order one party to pay the other's attorney’s fees in specific circumstances. Sarah Reusché explains.
The reconciliation process and the financial relationship between landlords and tenants.
By Theodore M. McGinn July 14, 2025
In commercial leases, particularly those involving retail or office spaces, tenants typically pay not only base rent but also a share of additional operating expenses. These include Common Area Maintenance (CAM) charges, property taxes, and insurance premiums. The reconciliation of these expenses is a key process.
Delaware Supreme Court’s Analysis of Indemnification Notices in Merger and Escrow Agreements
By Steven A. Migala July 11, 2025
Attorneys drafting or reviewing indemnification clauses and notice provisions in a sale or acquisition governed by Delaware law should be aware of the recent Delaware Supreme Court decision in Thompson Street Capital Partners IV L.P. v. Sonova U.S. Hearing Instruments, LLC.
Update on Illinois Tax Changes
By Timothy M. Hughes July 10, 2025
Beginning July 1, Illinois residents will face a series of tax increases related to the Fiscal Year 2026 budget, which takes effect from July 1, 2025, to June 30, 2026. These increases are from the $55+B state budget that is supposed to generate $700+M of new taxes ranging from gasoline, short-term rentals, and more.
Contaminated Cilantro and the Need to Provide Notice to a Seller of a Breach of the Implied Warranty
By Steven A. Migala June 30, 2025
Restaurant patrons allegedly became ill from eating contaminated cilantro and filed personal injury lawsuits against two Chicago restaurants. As part of the litigation, the distributor who sold the cilantro to the restaurants, Martin Produce, Inc., filed a third-party complaint for contribution against the wholesalers.
More Posts