Banking and Business Monthly – April 2024

Steven A. Migala • April 9, 2024

Delaware Chancery Court Nullifies Common Stockholder Agreement Terms

A man in a suit and tie is writing in a notebook.

In a significant ruling by the Delaware Court of Chancery, specific terms within a stockholder agreement were invalidated. Presided over by Vice Chancellor J. Travis Laster, the case of West Palm Beach Firefighters’ Pension Fund v. Moelis & Co., No. 2023-0309-JTL (Del. Ch. Feb. 23, 2024), scrutinized the limitations imposed on the board of directors’ authority by a stockholder agreement under the Delaware General Corporation Law (“DGCL”). This decision challenges the conventional structuring of stockholder agreements involving a controlling stockholder.


Moelis & Company, an internationally recognized investment bank, transitioned from a private to a public entity in 2014. Before its IPO, a stockholder agreement was reached between the company’s founder, Ken Moelis, and three affiliate entities, granting substantial rights and control over the company’s board of directors. Among the rights were comprehensive pre-approval rights spanning 18 distinct categories of board actions, including incurring certain debt, issuing securities, entering into new lines of business and certain contracts, hiring or firing officers, and issuing dividends (collectively, the “Pre-Approval Requirements”), and control over the board’s composition and committee structure.


The Delaware Court of Chancery’s decision to grant partial summary judgment in favor of the plaintiff invalidated several key components of the stockholder agreement. The court found that these components contravened Sections 141(a) and 141(c) of the DGCL, which safeguard the board’s authority to govern and manage the corporation’s affairs without undue interference. The court’s judgment zeroed in on those terms that effectively reallocated decision-making powers from the collective board to an individual, thereby diminishing the board’s inherent governance capabilities.


The court applied a two-pronged analysis aimed at discerning the nature of the contested terms. The first prong required the court to determine whether the stockholder agreement’s terms were part of an internal governance arrangement rather than an external commercial contract. Because this prong was satisfied, the court then examined the second prong, applying the Abercrombie test to gauge the extent of encroachment on directors’ managerial discretion and to invalidate terms that substantially limit directors’ judgment on management matters or restrict their decision-making. The analysis revealed that the Pre-Approval Requirements improperly delegated board authority and constrained directors’ independent judgment. Similarly, the agreement’s stipulations on board and committee composition were found to unlawfully restrict the board’s discretion, thus breaching the DGCL’s statutory mandates. 


However, the court did uphold the validity of three of the board composition provisions, (1) the designation right, allowing Mr. Moelis to designate a certain number of directors for election based on his percentage of voting power (subject to certain qualifications and limitations); (2) the nomination requirement, requiring the Board to nominate Mr. Moelis’ designees for election as directors; and (3) the efforts requirement, requiring the Company to use reasonable efforts to cause Mr. Moelis’ designees to be elected and continue to serve as directors. The court held these provisions did not violate the DGCL because they only allowed Mr. Moelis to identify and facilitate director candidates for election, but did not bind the Board to a particular course of action. 


The implications of this ruling extend beyond Moelis & Company, signaling a significant shift in the corporate governance of Delaware corporations. The decision underscores the critical importance of constructing stockholder agreements that respect the statutory authority of the board of directors. Delaware corporations are urged to review their governance documents, especially those pertaining to board authority and stockholder rights, to ensure compliance with the DGCL.


This verdict also prompts a broader reflection on corporate governance practices, encouraging businesses to explore alternative strategies for aligning interests between boards and stockholders. As suggested by the court, moving certain terms from stockholder agreements directly into the company’s certificate of incorporation may offer a legally sound avenue for achieving the objectives traditionally sought through stockholder agreements, because Section 141(a) of the DGCL expressly allows for charter-based limits on board authority. 


In sum, the Delaware Court of Chancery nullified many stockholder agreement terms previously thought to be “market” or common. This case highlights the necessity for companies to stay abreast of legal developments and to proactively adapt their corporate governance structures in response to evolving legal standards. Delaware corporations are advised to seek knowledgeable legal counsel to review their corporate governance documents and determine whether they remain enforceable. For further inquiries or questions, please contact me at smigala@lavellelaw.com or (847) 705-7555. Thanks go to Nathan Toy for his assistance with this month’s article.


More News & Resources

Lavelle Law News and Events

Divorce in 56 Days - a Lavelle Law Success Story
By Family Law Practice Group • November 18, 2026
Divorce is never easy, but it doesn't have to be prolonged or combative. When both parties are committed to a fair outcome and have attorneys focused on resolving the matter efficiently, a divorce can be completed in far less time than many people expect.
What Lenders Need to Know about UCC Article 9’s Commercial Reasonableness Standards After Marchi
By Steven A. Migala • November 17, 2026
When a borrower defaults on a loan, a lender often seeks to repossess and liquidate the collateral securing that debt. However, lenders are constrained in how they conduct those sales by Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code and its standard of commercial reasonableness under UCC Section 9-610(b).
IRS Expands Tax Pro Account for Business Client Payments
By Timothy M. Hughes • November 10, 2026
The Internal Revenue Service announced last week that authorized tax professionals can now make certain payments on behalf of their business clients through Tax Pro Account.
Illinois Condo and HOA Boards: Adopt a Written Collection Policy by January 1, 2027
By Robyn K. Kish • November 5, 2026
By January 1, 2027, condominium and common interest community associations in Illinois must adopt a written collection policy. Under the new law, an association that has not adopted the required policy will be prohibited from initiating legal action to collect delinquent assessments and other common expenses.
Lavelle Law Game Show Event Goes Buzzer to Buzzer
November 4, 2026
Lavelle Law Game Show Event Goes Buzzer to Buzzer - Lavelle Law in Schaumburg has grown over the last 30 years to become a multi-faceted law firm, with more than 40 attorneys who are experienced in numerous areas of law. But last month, the firm upped its game, so to speak.
Join us on 11.8.26 and learn to spot the red flags of fiduciary breach and know your rights.
By Lavelle Law • October 19, 2026
Lavelle Law Attorneys Kaiser and Kokoszka share stories from trust administration disputes, plus red flags of a fiduciary breach and how to protect yourself. Register today for "Tales from the Trenches on Trust Administration"
Banking and Business – October 2026
By Steven A. Migala • October 14, 2026
Federal Banking Regulators Clarify What Financial Institutions Can Tell Customers About Fraud Investigations and Account Closures
Tax Scams to Watch for Related to the One, Big, Beautiful Bill
By Timothy M. Hughes • October 10, 2026
Taxpayers should watch for the following OBBB-related scams and take steps to protect their personal and financial information.
Options and Tips for Selling Your Business - a Lavelle Law Minute video.
By Kerry M. Lavelle • September 29, 2026
Thinking of selling your business ahead of retirement? Business owners should begin preparing when they enter the “red zone” before retirement - not wait until they’re ready to retire. Kerry Lavelle explains this and more in the Lavelle Law Minute video, "Options and Tips for Selling Your Business."
Court Denies Petition to Remove Executor - Major Probate Litigation Defense Victory
By Probate Litigation • September 23, 2026
Court Denies Petition to Remove Executor - Major Probate Litigation Defense Victory - A Lavelle Law Success Story.
More Posts