Recorded Statement? – No Thank You!

Nicholas S. Dollenmaier • June 3, 2020
A lot of times after a person has been involved in a car crash, the at fault party’s insurance company gives them a call, sometimes hours after the collision, and asks for a recorded statement. Hardly ever is giving a recorded statement beneficial for the injured person and more often than not it can hurt his/her chances at recovery.
  
Unfortunately, most people do not see the harm in providing a recorded statement. Most believe that they were not at fault for the accident, were hurt from the accident, and the insurance company will make them “whole” after the accident if they agree to provide the recorded statement. Regrettably, this is not the case and instead of using that recorded statement to make the injured party whole, the insurance company uses it to discredit and sometimes take out of context a person’s words. This is especially true when the insurance company calls hours after the collision. When there is such proximity from the accident to the call, a person cannot be sure that they fully understand the extent of his/her injuries and should not be giving a detailed depiction of the collision itself. There is a good chance that hours after an accident, a person has not had the chance to fully digest the collision, what happened, may be experiencing the symptoms of shock, and are not able to fully realize their situation or their injuries.
   
This is why we always advise people who are on the fence about retaining a personal injury attorney to not provide a recorded statement until they make their decision. After we are retained, we are able to exert some control over the questions asked, format the conversation, and are able to take independent notes of what was said. Without us being there, the insurance company is able to retain the recording and independently assess how the conversation went. Absent filing a lawsuit, the insurance company is under no obligation to produce the recorded statement to the injured party. 

Unfortunately, the insurance company is aware that having an attorney on the line can be beneficial to a person’s case, which is why the call to obtain the recorded statement can come hours after the accident. If you are in this situation, politely refuse to give the recorded statement and make the decision whether you are going to hire a personal injury attorney early. We are here to help. Not only by guiding you through the recorded statement process, if we determine it beneficial to provide, but also ensuring you the most recovery for your case. There are many mistakes that can be made early on in a personal injury situation that can limit your recovery and with our experience; we can help you avoid those. 
   
In short, if you were involved in an accident and the insurance company asks for a recorded statement, politely say no thank you and think about whether you want to hire an attorney before returning the call.  

If you have been injured in an automobile accident or as a result of someone’s negligence, please contact attorney Nicholas Dollenmaier at 847-705-7555 or via email at ndollenmaier@lavellelaw.com to discuss your case and help get the compensation you deserve.

More News & Resources

Lavelle Law News and Events

Saved or client $1 Million in Estate Tax
By Estate Administration July 30, 2025
Due to Lavelle’s extensive knowledge in estate and gift tax, we were able to generate a combined federal and Illinois estate tax savings of $1 million for the client.
Don’t record a conversation without knowing the law in Illinois!
By Nataly Kaiser July 29, 2025
Do you know it’s a felony in Illinois if you record a conversation without consent? The Illinois Eavesdropping Statute prohibits the secret recording of private conversations without the consent of all parties involved. Protect yourself – Get consent before you hit record! Nataly Kaiser explains.
Now through 10-1-25, Lavelle Law is offering a special discounted rate on powers of attorney for col
By Jackie R. Luthringshausen July 24, 2025
Summer Special! - Now through 10-1-25, Lavelle Law is offering a special discounted rate on powers of attorney for college-bound students and young adults. Don't send your child to college without POA docs in place! Contact Attorney Luthringshausen to start the process. jluthringshausen@lavellelaw.com or 847-705-7555
A summary of The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) and its tax implications.
By Steven A. Migala July 22, 2025
The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), enacted on July 4, 2025, as Pub. L. No. 119-21, permanently extends and modifies key provisions from the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) while introducing new tax benefits and limitations. The law affects individuals, seniors, children, businesses, and charitable organizations.
An in-depth discussion of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act and its tax implications.
By Steven A. Migala and guest Ed Brooks July 21, 2025
Lavelle Law Shareholder Steven Migala and DHJJ Financial Principal Ed Brooks join host Jim Mitchell for an in-depth look at the new U.S. tax legislation, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, and discuss how it will impact both businesses and individuals.
An in-depth discussion of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act and its tax implications.
By Steven A. Migala and guest Ed Brooks July 21, 2025
Lavelle Law Shareholder Steven Migala and DHJJ Financial Principal Ed Brooks join host Jim Mitchell for an in-depth look at the new U.S. tax legislation, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, and discuss how it will impact both businesses and individuals.
What is a fee-shifting provision?
By Sarah J. Reusché July 15, 2025
In the United States, the "American Rule" generally requires each party in a legal dispute to cover their own attorney's fees, regardless of the case's outcome. However, exceptions exist where a judge may order one party to pay the other's attorney’s fees in specific circumstances. Sarah Reusché explains.
The reconciliation process and the financial relationship between landlords and tenants.
By Theodore M. McGinn July 14, 2025
In commercial leases, particularly those involving retail or office spaces, tenants typically pay not only base rent but also a share of additional operating expenses. These include Common Area Maintenance (CAM) charges, property taxes, and insurance premiums. The reconciliation of these expenses is a key process.
Delaware Supreme Court’s Analysis of Indemnification Notices in Merger and Escrow Agreements
By Steven A. Migala July 11, 2025
Attorneys drafting or reviewing indemnification clauses and notice provisions in a sale or acquisition governed by Delaware law should be aware of the recent Delaware Supreme Court decision in Thompson Street Capital Partners IV L.P. v. Sonova U.S. Hearing Instruments, LLC.
Update on Illinois Tax Changes
By Timothy M. Hughes July 10, 2025
Beginning July 1, Illinois residents will face a series of tax increases related to the Fiscal Year 2026 budget, which takes effect from July 1, 2025, to June 30, 2026. These increases are from the $55+B state budget that is supposed to generate $700+M of new taxes ranging from gasoline, short-term rentals, and more.
More Posts