Blog Post

Decision Regarding Refusal of DUI Breath Testing

James R. Doerr • Dec 05, 2016

Motorists first arrested for a DUI will face an immediate choice at the police station - should I submit or decline the breath test? A suspected DUI motorist may have many valid reasons for declining to submit to the chemical, breath or blood testing. It can be a simple matter of lack of willingness to cooperate, general distrust of police, adherence to advice of counsel, or any possible reason a person may give, rational or otherwise. No matter the reason, the prosecution will argue that the declining to submit to testing is a “refusal” and said refusal is due to the defendant’s “consciousness of guilt.” This can be powerful evidence to a jury. In order to bolster this argument, the prosecutor will point to the fact that the defendant was read a document called “Warning to Motorist”, which spells out the ramifications to a motorist’s driving privileges for a refusal to submit to, or failure of, chemical testing.

Illinois Vehicle Code specifically provides for the admissibility of evidence of a driver’s refusal to submit to blood-alcohol testing. 625 ILCS 5/11-501.2(c)(1) (West 2012). Both, the defendant and the state, recognize that evidence of refusal is allowed by statute and relevant case law. Specifically, courts have stated that; “[o]ur courts have long recognized that a defendant's refusal to take such a test is ‘relevant as circumstantial evidence of his consciousness of guilt.’” People v. Romanowski , 2016 IL App (1st) 142360, ¶ 17, quoting People v. Garriott , 253 Ill. App. 3d 1048, 1052 (1993). The defendant in Romanowski , however, argued that testimony of the arresting officer, as to the contents of the admonishment, should not have been allowed because such testimony is not specifically made admissible by section 11-501.2(c)(1). The state argued that the admission of this testimony was in the proper discretion of the circuit court.

The appellate court analyzed three of the following cases regarding the contents of warnings given to an arrested DUI suspect at trial; City of Rockford v. Elliott , 308 Ill. App. 3d 735, (1999), People v. Lynn , 388 Ill. App. 3d 272, (2009), and People v. Bock , 357 Ill. App. 3d 160, (2005).

In the case at bar, the appellate court followed the reasoning of People v. Lynn , 388 Ill. App. 3d 272, 277-78 (2009), and People v. Bock, 357 Ill. App. 3d 160, 170-71 (2005). Following Lynn and Bock and citing to Illinois Rule of Evidence 401 which states; “Evidence is considered relevant if it has “any tendency to make the existence of any fact that is of consequence to the determination of the action more probable or less probable than it would be without the evidence.” (eff. Jan. 1, 2011). The court held, “[l]ike the court in Lynn , we find the contents of the warning to motorists to be relevant circumstantial evidence of a defendant’s consciousness of his own guilt” Romanowski at ¶ 26.

The appellate court found that the circuit court did not abuse its discretion when allowing the arresting police officer to testify as to the actual admonishments given to the defendant.

It is important that a person facing a DUI or any other arrest seek the advice of counsel when confronted with these questions. For more information about this, or any other criminal law question, please contact James Doerr at 847-705-7555 or jdoerr@lavellelaw.com.

More News & Resources

Lavelle Law News and Events

Understanding the FTC’s Nationwide Ban on Noncompete Agreements
By Steven A. Migala 03 May, 2024
On April 23, 2024, the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”), in a 3-2 vote, issued its final Non-Compete Clause Rule (“Rule”) which prohibits noncompete clauses in agreements between employees and their workers. This highly anticipated Rule follows a substantially similar proposed rule from the FTC released on January 19, 2023. The Rule will not become effective until 120 days after publication in the Federal Register, and covered employers will be required to comply with the Rule by that effective date, which could come as early as August of this year. By the FTC’s estimate, this ban could affect up to one in five American workers.
Divorces that involve small and medium businesses have unique concerns and considerations.
By Joseph A. Olszowka 02 May, 2024
When determining how to distribute the marital assets between parties to a divorce, the division of an interest in a small or medium business owned by one or both of the parties is more complex and requires a careful examination of the value of the business or business interests. The Court must determine the value of the business interest in order to determine how to equitably divide all marital assets in which the parties have an interest. The Court will regularly rely on the valuation reports of the parties' experts regarding the value of the business. The business valuation expert will utilize a number of different methods in determining the value of a business. The professional appraiser will examine and assess the value of the business and provide expert testimony and reports to the parties and the Court.
Vehicle dealerships need to navigate the complex terrain of adhering to BIPA to avoid lawsuits.
By Sarah J. Reusché and Nathan Toy 30 Apr, 2024
Vehicle dealerships particularly have recently found themselves needing to navigate the complex terrain of adhering to the BIPA’s stringent requirements to avoid being targeted through lawsuits. There has been a recent noticeable uptick in class action lawsuits under the BIPA, serving as a critical wake-up call for the automotive retail industry, highlighting the need for dealerships to review and enhance their practices if they are using biometric technology.
Learn the complexities of Illinois commercial leases and avoid common pitfalls.
By Lavelle Law 29 Apr, 2024
Join us for this seminar as Lavelle Law attorneys Kelly Anderson and Chance Badertscher will unpack the complexities of Illinois commercial leases in order to prepare you for strong leasing relationships.
An essential part of a good contract is often overlooked. Learn about fee shifting provisions.
By Joseph O. Upchurch and MaryAllison Mahacek 23 Apr, 2024
Between the state of Illinois and federal courts, there are well over 200 statutes that deal with fee shifting provisions. They lay out ways in which legal fees may become the responsibility of one party in a lawsuit. In this video, Lavelle Law Associates Jodie Upchurch and MaryAllison Mahacek discuss ways that these provisions should be included in contracts and how they can be used advantageously.
Great advice on what to expect on your final walkthrough.
By Chance W. Badertscher 22 Apr, 2024
Lavelle Law real estate attorney, Chance Badertscher, recently participated in a Straight Up Chicago Investor Podcast and shared his expertise on what to expect on the final walkthrough before your real estate closing. He breaks it down and shares tips for both the buyer and the seller.
An essential part of a good contract is often overlooked. Learn about fee shifting provisions.
By Joseph O. Upchurch and MaryAllison Mahacek 18 Apr, 2024
Between the state of Illinois and federal courts, there are well over 200 statutes which deal with fee shifting provisions. They lay out ways in which legal fees may become the responsibility of one party in a lawsuit. Lavelle Law Associates Jodie Upchurch and MaryAllison Mahacek discuss ways that these provisions should be included in contracts and how they can be used advantageously.
Emergency Estate Tax Savings - a Lavelle Law Success Story
By Estate Planning and Administration 16 Apr, 2024
Our team worked very quickly (in a matter of just a few days) to establish temporary guardianship of the client, and – most importantly – successfully argued for the judge to authorize the guardian to execute and finalize the estate plan documents on the client’s behalf. Finalizing the estate planning documents in advance of the client’s death saved the estate and the client’s family nearly $500,000 in estate taxes.
Watch this video if you are considering setting up a medical spa in Illinois.
By Eso H. Akunne 12 Apr, 2024
Businesses classified as medical spas have a variety of special considerations that must be adhered to in the state of Illinois. In this video, Lavelle Law attorney Eso Akunne discusses critical issues that must be met to operate with state laws. If you are interested in getting involved in this rapidly growing industry be sure to watch this video.
Time to Claim a Refund Expires on May 17, 2024 Deadline, Then $1 Billion in Refunds Will be Lost.
By Timothy M. Hughes 10 Apr, 2024
The IRS recently announced that almost 940,000 people across the nation have unclaimed refunds for tax year 2020 but face a May 17 deadline to submit their tax returns. The IRS estimates more than $1 billion in refunds remain unclaimed because people have not filed their 2020 tax returns yet. The average median refund is $932 for 2020. The IRS estimates that about 36,200 Illinois taxpayers may lose $40,608,000 in potential refunds.
More Posts
Share by: