Class Action Case Against Facebook for Use of Facial Recognition Technology May Proceed

Brian J. Massimino • October 3, 2019

By a unanimous decision, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled that the case of Patel v. Facebook may proceed as a class action on behalf of Facebook users in Illinois under the State’s Biometric Information Privacy Act, 740 ILCS 14/1 et seq . (“BIPA”). For a brief overview of BIPA and its legislative intent, click here.

In its ruling, the Court overtly rejected Facebook's argument that the plaintiffs assert a mere procedural violation of BIPA insufficient to establish legal standing. The Court concluded that using facial recognition technology without consent (as alleged by the plaintiffs) "invades an individual's private affairs and concrete interests." 932 F.3d 1264, 1273 (9th Cir. 2019).

This decision (and others) leave no doubt that the use of biometric information is extremely risky. Each negligent violation could cost a business $1,000 and each intentional or reckless violation could cost $5,000. Anyone doing business in the State or with residents of the State of Illinois should proceed with extreme caution.

If your business uses, stores or transmits fingerprints, facial recognition, or similar biometric information, consider having Lavelle Law review your policies and procedures for compliance with BIPA. If your business has received a demand letter or lawsuit related to a violation of BIPA, contact Brian Massimino at bmassimino@lavellelaw.com or 312-736-1262 and defend your business.


More News & Resources

Lavelle Law News and Events

Should Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce lawyer up? What would their prenup look like?
By Joseph A. Olszowka and Kristina Buchthal Alkass September 12, 2025
Taylor Swift’s engagement to Travis Kelce has made a big splash in the news. In this podcast, Lavelle Law family law attorneys Joe Olszowka and Kristina Buchthal Alkass discuss the importance of prenuptial agreements - and not just for the wealthy.
Who qualifies for the
By Timothy M. Hughes September 10, 2025
The U.S. Treasury Department issued a preliminary list of nearly 70 jobs that qualify for “no tax on tips.” The occupations include a wide range of services spanning from Rickshaw drivers to digital content creators.
Does the Expiration of the Statute of Limitations for a Mortgage Extinguish the Mortgage Lien?
By Steven A. Migala September 4, 2025
On August 20, 2025, the First District of the Illinois Appellate Court decided Chicago Title Land Trust Co. v. Watkin, 2025 IL App (1st) 241354 (August 20, 2025). At issue in Watkin was whether the expiration of the statute of limitations barring enforcement of a mortgage also extinguishes the mortgage lien.
New Illinois Small Estate Affidavit Law: Key Updates for 2025
By Nataly Kaiser August 26, 2025
The Illinois General Assembly has updated the Probate Act of 1975 to improve the small estate affidavit process for settling estates without formal probate. Effective immediately, this amendment offers significant benefits for Illinois residents managing a loved one's estate.
Illinois family laws help determine who gets to keep the pet when couples divorce.
By Joseph A. Olszowka August 25, 2025
A common consideration in a divorce case is who will get to keep the family pet. Illinois has a specific law that addresses this issue. In this video, divorce attorney Joe Olszowka explains the various factors the court considers when there is a pet involved in an Illinois family law case.
Lavelle Saves Homeowner from Real Estate Tax Bill Disaster
By Litigation August 20, 2025
Lavelle Saves Homeowner from Real Estate Tax Bill Disaster - In the end, our client clawed back ownership of his family’s home and was made whole on the attorney fees he was forced to pay to rectify this unfortunate situation.
A summary of NADA’s statement defending state franchise laws.
By Sarah J. Reusché August 14, 2025
Recently, OEMs like Tesla and Rivian implemented a direct-to-consumer approach that many state motor vehicle dealer laws are intended to prohibit. On May 27, 2025, the National Automobile Dealers Association (NADA) submitted a Public Comment, defending state franchise laws.
Free Family Law Seminar in Schaumburg, IL
By Family Law August 11, 2025
Join Lavelle Law for an informative presentation tailored to individuals seeking expert guidance on critical family law matters. Our experienced family law attorneys will break down three key areas — prenuptial/postnuptial agreements, collaborative divorce, and child custody.
IRS outlined key points for tax year 2025 relating to the OBBBA provisions.
By Timothy M. Hughes August 10, 2025
On August 7, 2025, the IRS announced that, as part of its phased implementation of the July 4th One Big Beautiful Bill Act, there will be no changes to certain information returns or withholding tables for tax year 2025 related to the new law. The IRS outlined key relevant changes to tax filers effective for '25 - '28.
Saved or client $1 Million in Estate Tax
By Estate Administration July 30, 2025
Due to Lavelle’s extensive knowledge in estate and gift tax, we were able to generate a combined federal and Illinois estate tax savings of $1 million for the client.
More Posts