Banking and Business – June 2025

Steven A. Migala • June 30, 2025

Contaminated Cilantro and the Need to Provide Notice to a Seller of a Breach of the Implied Warranty of Merchantability


Background

 

Restaurant patrons allegedly became ill from eating contaminated cilantro and filed personal injury lawsuits against two Chicago restaurants. As part of the litigation, the distributor who sold the cilantro to the restaurants, Martin Produce, Inc. (Martin), filed a third-party complaint for contribution against the wholesalers from whom it purchased the cilantro, including Jack Tuchten Wholesale Produce, Inc. (Tuchten), alleging the wholesalers breached an implied warranty of merchantability. Before Martin brought its claim, Tuchten was a named defendant in the underlying personal injury lawsuits, and Tuchten answered them and participated in discovery.

 

At issue in this case was whether the distributor satisfied its obligation to notify the wholesaler of its claim of breach of the implied warranty of merchantability pursuant to section 2-607(3)(a) of the Illinois Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), 810 ILCS 5/2-607(3)(a). Martin alleged in its third-party complaint that Tuchten had actual notice of the alleged defect of the cilantro as a result of being named as a defendant in the personal injury lawsuits. Tuchten, on the other hand, argued that these allegations in a complaint did not constitute direct notice of the claim of breach of implied warranty.

 

Decision

 

The Illinois Supreme Court held that Tuchten being named defendant in the underlying litigation was enough to constitute sufficient notice under UCC §2-607(3)(a). Andrews v. Carbon on 26th, LLC, 2025 IL 130862. For breach of implied warranty of merchantability claims, UCC §2-607(3)(a) states that the buyer must, within a reasonable time after discovering or after it should have discovered any breach, notify the seller of breach or be barred from any remedy. While the general rule is that a buyer must directly notify the seller of the troublesome nature of the transaction or be barred from recovering for a breach of warranty, the court noted two exceptions. First, a buyer can fulfill the notice requirement without giving direct notice to the seller where the seller has actual knowledge of the defect of the particular product. Second, a consumer buyer who has suffered personal injuries from a defective product can satisfy the notice requirement simply by filing a complaint alleging a breach of warranty against the seller. While it is unnecessary to list specific claims of breach of warranty in giving notice under 810 ILCS 5/2-607, it is essential that the seller be notified that this particular transaction is troublesome and must be watched.


Here, the court determined that only the first exception was applicable since Martin is not a consumer buyer. The court then determined that Tuchten had actual notice because, before Martin filed its complaint on April 16, 2019, the wholesalers were aware of the buyer, the particular product, the alleged defects, and the specific transactions at issue, based on being named as defendants in the personal injury complaints.


Takeaways

 

As a buyer, you should directly inform the seller as soon as you discover a problem with a product that gives rise to a breach of the implied warranty of merchantability under UCC §2-314. As the court noted, the general rule is that direct notice is required. Nevertheless, the court confirmed that actual knowledge can arise from a number of sources, and whether the buyer has provided sufficient notice to the seller is a question of fact that turns on the particular circumstances of each case. Thus, if direct notice is not provided, there are other avenues a buyer can look towards to satisfy the actual notice requirement in an implied breach of warranty case.

 

Thanks go to our summer associate Ayisha Kecht for her help writing this article. For further inquiries or questions, please contact me at smigala@lavellelaw.com or (847) 705-7555.


More News & Resources

Lavelle Law News and Events

Divorce in 56 Days - a Lavelle Law Success Story
By Family Law Practice Group • November 18, 2026
Divorce is never easy, but it doesn't have to be prolonged or combative. When both parties are committed to a fair outcome and have attorneys focused on resolving the matter efficiently, a divorce can be completed in far less time than many people expect.
What Lenders Need to Know about UCC Article 9’s Commercial Reasonableness Standards After Marchi
By Steven A. Migala • November 17, 2026
When a borrower defaults on a loan, a lender often seeks to repossess and liquidate the collateral securing that debt. However, lenders are constrained in how they conduct those sales by Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code and its standard of commercial reasonableness under UCC Section 9-610(b).
IRS Expands Tax Pro Account for Business Client Payments
By Timothy M. Hughes • November 10, 2026
The Internal Revenue Service announced last week that authorized tax professionals can now make certain payments on behalf of their business clients through Tax Pro Account.
Illinois Condo and HOA Boards: Adopt a Written Collection Policy by January 1, 2027
By Robyn K. Kish • November 5, 2026
By January 1, 2027, condominium and common interest community associations in Illinois must adopt a written collection policy. Under the new law, an association that has not adopted the required policy will be prohibited from initiating legal action to collect delinquent assessments and other common expenses.
Lavelle Law Game Show Event Goes Buzzer to Buzzer
November 4, 2026
Lavelle Law Game Show Event Goes Buzzer to Buzzer - Lavelle Law in Schaumburg has grown over the last 30 years to become a multi-faceted law firm, with more than 40 attorneys who are experienced in numerous areas of law. But last month, the firm upped its game, so to speak.
Join us on 11.8.26 and learn to spot the red flags of fiduciary breach and know your rights.
By Lavelle Law • October 19, 2026
Lavelle Law Attorneys Kaiser and Kokoszka share stories from trust administration disputes, plus red flags of a fiduciary breach and how to protect yourself. Register today for "Tales from the Trenches on Trust Administration"
Banking and Business – October 2026
By Steven A. Migala • October 14, 2026
Federal Banking Regulators Clarify What Financial Institutions Can Tell Customers About Fraud Investigations and Account Closures
Tax Scams to Watch for Related to the One, Big, Beautiful Bill
By Timothy M. Hughes • October 10, 2026
Taxpayers should watch for the following OBBB-related scams and take steps to protect their personal and financial information.
Options and Tips for Selling Your Business - a Lavelle Law Minute video.
By Kerry M. Lavelle • September 29, 2026
Thinking of selling your business ahead of retirement? Business owners should begin preparing when they enter the “red zone” before retirement - not wait until they’re ready to retire. Kerry Lavelle explains this and more in the Lavelle Law Minute video, "Options and Tips for Selling Your Business."
Court Denies Petition to Remove Executor - Major Probate Litigation Defense Victory
By Probate Litigation • September 23, 2026
Court Denies Petition to Remove Executor - Major Probate Litigation Defense Victory - A Lavelle Law Success Story.
More Posts